Pogue Picks Paperwhite, and Three Reasons that Educators Won’t

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+Email this to someoneShare on LinkedIn

David Pogue, the uber-tech-reviewer for the New York Times, took a minute this week to decipher the place of the new Kindle Paperwhite in the still robust market for E-Ink-based readers. On balance, I think he got it right. The Paperwhite addresses a concern long held by a certain segment of e-book aficionados: how to read in bed next to a sleeping spouse without turning a light on. (And apparently this segment is a large one.) With the Paperwhite, it is game on (and lights out)!

So, why won’t this new device resonate with educators? As has been the case throughout the history of the Kindle, improvements to the device have been made with one audience in mind: the retail consumer. And often, improvements that serve the consumer do not serve the purposes of education, as we have documented regularly in this space.

The Paperwhite is no exception. Backlighting and more pristine contrast are not features that have much relevance to school. But there are several shortcomings in the Paperwhite that are extremely relevant to educators:

  1. No removable storage – You may have forgotten that the original Kindle had a slot for an SD card. For a school, the ability to load SD cards with books and then insert them into whatever Kindle device is handy is a useful feature. That way the inventory of books can be separated from the inventory of devices. The average consumer doesn’t need this, but a school librarian juggling and deploying resources does.
  2. No charger included – A wall charger for the Paperwhite costs $10. Most schools will need one of these. Per device.
  3. Advertisements – Ads appear on the standard Paperwhite, which are meant to induce buying behaviors that most educators fret about when the Kindle is in the student’s hands. Yes, they are unobtrusive and do not really interfere with the screen while reading, but there is a strong precedent that educational materials not contain advertisements. Anyone remember Chris Whittle and Channel One? If you want to remove them, that’ll be $20.

I used to make the case that the Kindle 1 was the best Kindle for education. The Paperwhite doesn’t really change that opinion.

How does the competition stack up on these items? The Nook Simple Touch e-ink e-reader:

  1. Has a slot for removable storage
  2. Includes a wall charger with the unit
  3. Does not display advertisements

‘Nuff said?

 

 

 

 

 

  4 comments for “Pogue Picks Paperwhite, and Three Reasons that Educators Won’t

  1. willd
    October 22, 2012 at 10:00 am

    Excellent news–thanks Mike! Need to investigate this as it would resolve a real issue for most schools.

  2. MikeOnBike
    October 17, 2012 at 12:49 pm
  3. willd
    October 7, 2012 at 7:43 pm

    Excellent points, Mike. The ability of a card to go wandering is a big issue. However, most school implementations I have seen do require devices to be on chargers when not in use (so as to avoid interruptions that come from drained batteries). Historically, Amazon has not offered an education discount, except, perhaps, on very large orders. The management of the devices sometimes is, sadly, more important than what they can do for students.

  4. MikeOnBike
    October 5, 2012 at 1:39 pm

    For #1, can every Kindle share an account and download from the cloud with Wi-Fi? I would think removable (tiny) microSD cards would be a liability in a school.

    For #2, the Kindles don’t need to be charged nightly, so a charger per device is probably overkill.

    For #3, at least it’s an option.

    How big a discount does Amazon’s Education Sales department provide? Enough to solve #2 and #3?

Comments are closed.